Sub-lethal toxicity of indigo dye (Indigofera tinctoria) on Oreochromis niloticus juveniles
Bulletin of the National Research Centre volume 47, Article number: 86 (2023)
Textile dyes which are eliminated as unfixed dyes through the effluent from textile industry cause deleterious effect on the fresh water fish. Thus, toxicity tests were conducted using indigo dye on Oreochromis niloticus juveniles (mean weight 30.00 ± 0.73 g) as a test fish under bioassay system. Varying concentration of 0.00 (control), 0.5, 1.0, 1.5, 2.0, and 2.5 mg/l containing graded levels of Indigofera were applied in experimental tanks to determine the lethal concentration. The LC50 of dye at 96 h was 1.3 mg/l of water. The histopathology (heart, gills, kidney and spleen) and water quality parameters (Dissolved oxygen, pH and temperature) were determined using standard methods and behavioural responses were observed.
Histopathology of heart, gills, kidney and spleen revealed degeneration of cells, space formation, slight cellular changes and vacuolation among the treatments especially in the higher concentration of 1.5 mg/l, 2.0 mg/l, and 2.5 mg/l of the dye solution used except in the control. The pH and DO of control were significantly different from the experimental units while there was no significant variation in the temperature of the control and all the experimental units. Effects of indigo dye on water parameters were significant (P < 0.05) throughout the experiment. Behavioural responses exhibited by the experimental fish include irregular swimming, hyperventilation, rapid opercula movement, and restlessness. The dye concentration and exposure period both boosted these behaviours.
The findings of this study indicated that indigo dye solution is toxic to fish, and that fish opercula movement and mortality were influenced by the dosage of each concentration and the duration of exposure.
The textile industry has been branded as one of the biggest polluters in the world due to its extensive use of chemicals and water. A dye is typically a coloured organic substance or mixture that can be used to impart color in a somewhat permanent way to a substrate like cloth, paper, plastic, or leather (Velusamy et al. 2021). Approximately 10–15% of the colours used during the dyeing process are discharged as effluents. The majority of dyes are non-biodegradable, mutagenic, carcinogenic, and possibly hazardous to humans and other living things, particularly aquatic life (Parmar and Shah 2020; Makwana 2020). Natural dyes which can also be referred to as local dyes have been used since ancient times for colouring and printing fabrics. Among these are Indigofera which is the oldest known dye and a product of Indigofera leaves. The solution contains indigotin which always appear in deep-navy blue colour when used on white fabrics (Sabina et al. 2020).
The release of textile effluents to receiving streams may be problematic for several esthetic reasons since the effluents from the dyeing and textile industries contain chemicals with strong colours. The dye effluents may contain some substances or components that could be harmful, mutagenic, carcinogenic, or poisonous to aquatic life (Nasrin et al. 2022). Aquatic species may experience cramping, hypertension, occasional fever, kidney damage, and other physiological issues as a result of ingesting textile effluents through the food chain (Sabina et al. 2020). Many authors (Parmar and Shah 2020; Makwana 2020; Sabina et al. 2020; Velusamy et al. 2021; Nasrin et al. 2022) have reported the toxicities of certain dyes on fishes and it was revealed that freshwater fishes are the most widely affected aquatic organisms due to pollutants. Therefore, one of the biggest risks to people and other aquatic animals is the discharge of dyes into the environment, notably from the textile and dyeing industries.
However, certain aquatic species continue to employ specific colours as a cost-effective and efficient technique of treating parasite and fungus infestations. Fish and fish eggs have traditionally used malachite green as an antifungal agent. Additionally used to cure and prevent fish disease include acriflavine and methylene blue. All of these medications are widely promoted for ornamental (non-food) fish uses, even though none of them have been licensed for use in the production of food fish. They could be employed improperly or illegally in both domestic and international aquaculture. Other dyes are commonly sold for treating external diseases in ornamental fish and show comparable antibacterial effects. The use of any of these substances in the production of edible fish is unregulated (Velusamy et al. 2021).
Despite all these information on the effects of dyes on fish, there is paucity of information on the toxicological, behavioural and growth responses of O. niloticus exposed to dye effluents. Since some of these local dyes especially Indigofera are still used in some parts of Nigeria to colour fabrics, it has a potential of affecting fish production through mortality, susceptibility to disease, residual effect on the fish and health hazard on the final consumer. Therefore, the purpose of this study was to examine the effects of various indigo dye concentrations on the behaviour and histopathological reactions of the spleen, gill, heart, and kidney of Oreochromis niloticus. Fish embryos, larvae, and early juvenile stages are considered to be the most sensitive life-history stages to toxins, which makes them the ideal time to study how the fish react to environmental contaminants (Owolabi et al. 2021). Hence, juveniles of O. niloticus were used in this study.
Sample collection and pre-exposure acclimation of experimental fish
Indigo dye was collected from the indigenous women involved in cottage making in Abeokuta, Ogun State, Southwest Nigeria. Doses of indigo dye were estimated and each dose was measured by micropipette and blended with aquarium water while healthy and active specimens of Oreochromis niloticus juveniles were obtained as experimental fish from the Teaching and Research Farm of the Federal University of Technology Akure, Ondo State Nigeria. Fishes were acclimatized under laboratory conditions for two weeks. The fishes were fed twice a day (8:00 h and 16:00 h) with commercial floating feed (40% protein) up to satiation. The water medium was changed daily. This assisted in getting rid of waste feed, feces, and other undesirable elements. All experiments were approved by the appropriate ethical review committee of the Central Research Laboratory, Federal University of Technology Akure, Nigeria.
After 14 days of acclimatization, based on estimated 96-h LC50 (1.3 mg/L), healthy juvenile of Oreochromis niloticus weighing 30.00 ± 0.73 g were exposed to five sub-lethal concentrations of indigo dye (0.5, 1.0, 1.5, 2.0, and 2.5 mg/L) and control (0.0 mg/L) in triplicates. A total of 180 individuals were allocated to eighteen 100 L glass aquaria (10 fish per tank). The fishes were fed twice a day (8:00 h and 16:00 h) with commercial floating feed (40% protein) up to satiation (Owolabi et al. 2021). Unutilized feedstuffs and fecal wastes were cleansed by siphoning. Water was changed after 24 h with previously prepared water with appropriate indigo dye dosages. Control tanks were also maintained under the laboratory condition. The death rates and behavioural disorders were observed every 24 h. Three fishes were sampled from each tank to collect heart, gill, spleen and kidney samples for histopathological examination after the exposure period was over. Samples were immediately fixed in 10% formalin for histopathological observation later.
Determination of physico-chemical properties of water
The dissolved oxygen (DO), pH and temperature concentration were determined and their readings were recorded daily. A mercury-in-glass thermometer was used to measure the temperature; it was immersed into the experimental tank for 1 min before measurements were taken. The DO concentration was determined with a DO meter (Model HI 9828) while pH was determined using a manual pH meter Ohaus starter 3100, OHAUS Corporation, USA according to Ajibare et al. (2022).
For histopathological studies, the tissues (gill, heart, spleen and kidney) were collected in 10% formalin. They were processed routinely for paraffin embedding and sectioned to 5 µm thickness with a microtome machine (HM 430; Thermo-Scientific). The tissue slices were arranged on slides like ribbons and stained with standard Haematoxylene-Eosin (H-E) protocol before being mounted with DPX and a coverslip. Finally, stained slides were examined under a microscope for histopathological abnormalities in the tissues (Owolabi 2011).
Calculation of percentage mortality
The percentage mortality rate was calculated according to Owolabi (2011) as follows:
Comparison of the effects of the different concentrations of indigo dye was performed by analysis of variance (ANOVA) on IBM SPSS 20.0. The means were separated with New Duncan Multiple Range Tests at P < 0.05 using IBM SPSS 20.0.
Water quality parameters
The physico-chemical parameters of the experimental water are presented in Table 1. The table showed slight changes in all the parameters used throughout the 96 h experiment. The three parameters that were monitored were temperature, dissolved oxygen and pH. The result showed that the pH (6.70 ± 0.27) and DO (5.80 ± 0.28 mg/l) of control were significantly different from the values observed in the experimental units while there was no significant variation in the temperature of the control and all the experimental units.
Fish behavioural response to Indigo dye
The result of this study (as presented in Table 2) revealed that the 150 fish exposed to varying concentration of dye exhibited irregular swimming, hyperventilation, rapid movement of the opercula, restlessness, etc. and it was observed that the behavioural responses were dependent on concentration and exposure duration i.e. the higher the concentration of the indigo dye the higher the level of abnormality displayed by the fishes. Table 2 further revealed that the fish exposed to concentration less than 1.5 mg/l of dye in 24 h did not exhibit any abnormal behaviour while those exposed to concentration of less than 1.0 mg/l in 48 h did not display abnormal behaviours. However, the table revealed all the treatments exhibited all the observed abnormal behaviours at 72 h and 96 h while all the fish in the control tank exhibited normal behaviours throughout the experiment. Similarly, the mortality rate of exposed fish was concentration and exposure period dependent (Table 2). The table revealed that 10%, 60% and 90% mortality was recorded for 1.5 mg/l, 2.0 mg/l and 2.5 mg/l, respectively, after 24 h. The mortality rate after 48 h also revealed that 10%, 80% and 100% mortality was recorded in the fish exposed to 1.5 mg/l, 2.0 mg/l and 2.5 mg/l. Also, after 72 h, the mortality rate was 10%, 20%, 100% and 100% for 1.0 mg/l, 1.5 mg/l, 2.0 mg/l and 2.5 mg/l, respectively, while the order recorded after 96 h was 20%, 30%, 60%, 100% and 100% for 0.5 mg/l, 1.0 mg/l, 1.5 mg/l, 2.0 mg/l and 2.5 mg/l, respectively. The table showed that there was no mortality in the control experiments throughout the study.
The histopathological observations of the heart, gills, kidney and spleen of O. niloticus juveniles exposed to varying concentration of indigo dye are presented in Table 3 and Figs. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6. The result revealed that some alterations including vacuolation, space formation, scattering of cells, shrinkage and dissolution of nucleus as well as degeneration of cell structure were observed in the organs (heart, gills, spleen and kidney) of the fish exposed to different concentration of indigo dye solution especially at high concentration of the dye (Table 3; Figs. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6).
The discharge of indigo dye into water as revealed by the minor acidic range of the pH (5.80–7.55) recorded, may contribute to an increase in the primary productivity of water bodies. Researchers such as Odeyemi et al. (2018), Deepika and Noorjahan (2018), Velusamy et al. (2021), Alaguprathana and Poonkothai (2021) and Nasrin et al., (2022) have also reported similar effects of dyes on aquatic media and attributed the rise in loads of major ions to organic pollution. The abnormal behavior changes such as fast jerking, frequent jumping, erratic swimming, spiraling, convulsion, and a propensity to escape the experimental tanks, are consistent with those discovered by Selvaraj et al. (2015) and Kishore et al. (2022) in Poecilia recticulata and Clarias batrachus, respectively.
The result of this study also revealed that indigo dye were toxic to the experimental fish, resulting in both external and internal harm, including body darkening, copious mucous secretion (a defense mechanism), and dye deposition over the exterior (gills) and internal organs (lateral line and digestive system). This observation was in agreement with the findings of Jacquin et al. (2020), Alaguprathana and Poonkothai (2021) and Barathinivas et al. (2022) who reported that fish exposed to sub-lethal levels of pollution typically exhibit hyperactivity, changes in opercula rate, unpredictable and sudden jerky swimming movements, and other behavioural patterns, which have been shown to be sensitive indicators of physiological stress. Also, Ajibare et al (2022) suggested that increased opercular movement in fish may be a sign of stress and may lead to physiological dysfunction in the fish. This opercular movement may be brought on by a decrease in the efficiency of oxygen intake or transport. The 96 LC50 of indigo dye to O. niloticus was 1.3 ml/l. The rate at which the organisms die was also used as criterion for toxicities (dye effect). Other behaviours observed before the death of the organisms were loss of reflex, discolouration, high rate of respiration. The results of this study supported the findings of Authman and Abbas (2007) that the exposure of Oreochromis mossambicus to ammonia caused clinical indications such unusual movements and abnormal respiration rate that presented brain dysfunction and gill damage. Therefore, increased gill injury may be contributing to the high fish mortality rate by impairing gaseous exchange (Jacquin et al. 2020).
Findings of this study about the morphological changes in gills were consistent with several earlier similar studies (Parmar and Shah 2020; Alaguprathana and Poonkothai 2021; Kishore et al. 2022). Fish exposed to dye had gills with hyperplasia, aneurisms, raising of the gill epithelium, twisted secondary gill lamellae, and a degraded central axis (Jagruti 2015; Parmar and Shah 2020). Selvaraj et al. (2015), Makwana (2020) and Gao et al. (2021) have also documented histopathological alterations (including expansion of the primary gill bar, detachment of the secondary gill bar, and haematocyte infiltration into the lumen) in Poecilia recticulata, Clarias batrachus and Takifugu rubripes, respectively. However, in the presence of dye or other toxicants, epithelial lifting has been demonstrated by Parmar and Shah (2020) as a protective response to maintain the distance between secondary gill lamellae and toxicant, making secondary gill lamellae curvier and potentially affecting the structure and functions of the entire gill.
This study's histopathological findings in the kidney and gill were highly congruent with earlier studies by Athira and Jaya (2018) and Sabina et al. (2020), which established that fish gill exhibit cytoplasmic vacuolation and bunching of nuclei after exposure to textile dyeing effluent, and that the kidney experiences nucleus breakdown with loss of chromatin materials. The histopathological observation of the vital organs of fish exposed to low sub-lethal concentrations of indigo dye (as shown in Figs. 2 and 3) revealed that there was slight cellular changes (space formation and scattering of cells) low vacuolation with inflammation. However, there was extensive necrosis and total degeneration of cell /nucleus with loss of chromatin materials at very high concentration of indigo dye (Fig. 6). Similarly, Fatma and Mohamed (2009) observed intravascular hemolysis in hepatic blood vessels and hepatoportal blood vessels, as well as vacuolar degeneration in the hepatocytes, focal areas of necrosis and aggregations of inflammatory cells between the hepatocytes, dilation and thrombosis formation in central veins, dilation and congestion in blood sinusoids in the liver of Tilapia zilli and Solea vulgaris from the lake Qarun contaminated with different pollutants. Additionally, Koca et al. (2008), Kaur and Mishra (2019) documented a number of histopathological changes including inflated and ruptured parenchymal cells, loss of cord structure, vacuoles packed with cellular debris, focal necrosis, and a significant rise in kupffer cells in the liver as a result of accumulation of toxicants.
The outcome of this study was corroborated by earlier investigations on the effects of various dyes on different species of fish (Avni and Barot 2016; Deepika and Noorjahan 2018; Parmar and Shah 2019, 2020; Velusamy et al. 2021; Alaguprathana and Poonkothai 2021). This research also supports the findings of Kirandeep et al. (2015), who demonstrated that the concentration-dependent cytogenotoxicity of the azo dye Acid Blue-113 caused harm to all examined target tissues (brain, liver, kidneys, and reproductive system) in the study of C. punctatus. Moreover, the study's findings on the toxicity of indigo dye are consistent with the experiment done by Al-Sabti (2000) on the genotoxic effects of textile dyes like chlorotriazine-reactive azo red on aquatic ecosystems. As a result, our work has shown that information on fish mortality and their histopathological and behavioral responses is relevant for estimating the sub-lethal toxicity of contaminants. In order to start corrective measures for ecosystem health, water managers who rely on fish survival data for wastewater discharge in water courses must also analyze fish health for detecting toxicity at higher dilutions. Therefore, the government must take action to prevent the indiscriminate siting of small- and large-scale textile mills in order to protect the environment since indigo dye and textile effluents pose a possible risk to the receiving water body.
According to the findings of this study, Oreochromis niloticus exhibited morphological, behavioral, and histopathological changes at various concentrations of indigo dye. The responses of Oreochromis niloticus to the various concentrations of indigo dye solution showed that the dye (Indigofera) was toxic to the fish while the dosage of each concentration and the length of exposure time affected the fish opercula movement and histopathological changes such as degeneration of cells, space formation, slight cellular changes and vacuolation (as observed in the fish). Also, exposure to indigo dyes suppressed the aerobic respiration and triggered the anaerobic respiration. Therefore, in order to maintain the aquatic system, the indiscriminate use of synthetic chemical dyes should be limited and replaced with eco-friendly dyes. Moreover, proper usage, handling and disposal should be strictly considered and monitored.
Availability of data and materials
All data generated or analysed during this study are included in this article. The datasets generated during and/or analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request. The data used to support the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon request.
Analysis of variance
- LC50 :
Median lethal concentration
Adeyanju O, Emanuel SE, Akomolafe SF (2011) Extraction of Indigo dye (powdered form) from the leaf of Indigofera tinctoria. Int J Phys Sci 6(1):137–143
Ajibare AO, Loto OO, Ayeku PO, Amulejoye FD (2022) Toxicity of the herbicide glyphosate: effects on behavioural and growth responses of juvenile Clarias gariepinus. Book of abstracts of the First Scientific Conference of the Faculty of Applied Science, Kola Daisi University, Ibadan held at Kola Daisi University Ibadan, Nigeria, 1st to 4th March, 2022
Alaguprathana M, Poonkothai M (2021) Haematological, biochemical, enzymological and histological responses of Labeo rohita exposed to methyl orange dye solution treated with Oedogonium subplagiostomum AP1. Environ Sci Pollut Res 28(14):17602–17612
Al-Sabti K (2000) Chlorotriazine reactive azo red 120 textile dye induces micronuclei in fish. Ecotoxicol Environ Saf 47:149–155
Athira N, Jaya DS (2018) The use of fish biomarkers for assessing textile effluent contamination of aquatic ecosystems: a review. Nat Environ Pollut Technol 17(1):25–34
Authman MM, Abbas HH (2007) Accumulation and distribution of copper and zinc in both water and some vital tissues of two fish species (Tilapia zillii and Mugil cephalus) of Lake Qarun, Fayoum Province, Eqypt. Pak J Biol Sci 10:2106–2122
Avni P, Barot J (2016) Determination of genotoxic effect of azo dye CI RR 120 on fish Catla catla. Biotechnol Res 2:77–80
Barathinivas A, Ramya S, Neethirajan K, Jayakumararaj R, Pothiraj C, Balaji P et al (2022) Ecotoxicological effects of pesticides on hematological parameters and oxidative enzymes in freshwater Catfish. Mystus Keletius Sustain 14(15):9529
Deepika T, Noorjahan C (2018) Impact of untreated and treated textile effluent on haematological parameters of fresh water fish, Tilapia mossambica. Int J Adv Sci Res Manag 3(6):24–28
Gao X-Q, Fei F, Huang B, Meng XS, Zhang T, Zhao K-F et al (2021) Alterations in hematological and biochemical parameters, oxidative stress, and immune response in Takifugu rubripes under acute ammonia exposure. Comp Biochem Physiol C Toxicol Pharmacol 243:108978
Jacquin L, Petitjean Q, Côte J, Laffaille P, Jean S (2020) Effects of pollution on fish behavior, personality, and cognition: Some research perspectives. Front Ecol Evol 8:86
Jagruti B (2015) Evaluation of Azo dye toxicity using some haematological and histopathological alterations in fish Catla catla. Int J Biol Food Vet Agric Eng 9(5):388391
Kaur G, Mishra B (2019) Histopathological changes in liver of fish Channa punctatus exposed to sub lethal concentration of hybrid pesticide. Int J Biol Innov 1(2):83–86
Kirandeep K, Arvinder K, Rajvir K (2015) Cytogenotoxicity of azo dye acid blue-113 (AB-113) to Channa punctatus (BLOCH). J Environ Res Dev 9(3):547–554
Kishore D, Shubhajit S, Chukwuka AV, Chandra SN (2022) Behavioural toxicity and respiratory distress in early life and adult stage of walking catfish Clarias batrachus (Linnaeus) under acute fluoride exposures. Toxicol Environ Heal Sci 14(1):33–46
Koca S, Koca YB, Yildiz S, Gurcu B (2008) Genotoxic and histopathological effects of water pollution on two fish species, Barbus capitopectoralis and Chondrostoma nasus in the Buyuk Menderes River. Turkey Biol Trace Elem Res 122:276–291
Makwana S (2020) Acute toxicity and haematological studies of textile based industrial effluent of Pali City on a freshwater fish Clarias batrachus (L). Nat Environ Pollut Technol 19(5):1995–2003
Mohamed FAS (2009) Histopathological studies on Tilapia zilli and Solea vulgaris from Lake Qarun. Egypt World J Fish Mar Sci 1:2939
Nasrin T, Saha AK, Mohanta MK, Chaity AS, Alam MJ, Shawon MH, Haque MF (2022) Reduction of toxic effects of textile dye, Basic Red-18 on Tilapia Fish by bioremediation with a novel bacterium, Mangrovibacter yixingensis strain AKS2 isolated from textile wastewater. Annu Res Rev Biol 37(11):12–29. https://doi.org/10.9734/ARRB/2022/v37i1130544
Odeyemi OE, Adedeji AA, Odeyemi OJ (2018) Effects of discharge from carwash on the physico-chemical parameters and zooplanktonic abundance of Odo-Ebo River, Ile-Ife, Nigeria. Acta Univ Sapientiae Agric Environ 10:83–96. https://doi.org/10.2478/ausae-2018-0007
Owolabi OD (2011) Haematological and serum biochemical profile of the upside-down catfish Synodontis membranacea Geoffroy Saint Hilaire from Jebba Lake, Nigeria. Comp Clin Pathol 20:163–172. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00580-10-0973-x
Owolabi OD, Abdulkareem SI, Ajibare AO (2021) Haemato-biochemical and ionic regulatory responses of the hybrid catfish, Heteroclarias, to sublethal concentrations of palm oil mill effluents. Bull Natl Res Centre 45:220. https://doi.org/10.1186/s42269-021-00679-8
Parmar A, Shah A (2019) Cytogenotoxicity of azo dye Reactive Red 120 (RR120) on fish Catla catla. Environ Exp Biol 17:151–155
Parmar AI, Shah AI (2020) Haematological parameters and histopathological alterations in the gills of fish, Catla catla exposed to azo dye acid red–97. Adv Zool Bot 8(4):342–350
Sabina S, Fahmida A, Sahadat H (2020) Cytogenotoxic effects of acid dye on Channa punctatus (Bloch). Int J Fish Aquat Stud 8(5):220–225
Selvaraj D, Leena R, Kamal DC (2015) Toxicological and histopathological impacts of textile dyeing industry effluent on a selected teleost fish Poecilia reticulata. Asian J Pharmacol Toxicol 03(10):26–30
Velusamy S, Roy A, Sundaram S, Kumar MT (2021) A review on heavy metal ions and containing dyes removal through graphene oxide-based adsorption strategies for textile wastewater treatment. Chem Rec 21(7):1570–1610
The authors acknowledge the contributions of Dr. Patrick Ayeku of Department of Biosciences and Biotechnology, University of Medical Sciences, Ondo, Ondo State, Nigeria during the laboratory and statistical analyses.
This study received no specific support from public, private, or non-profit funding bodies.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
The authors confirm that all experiments were carried out following the approval of the appropriate ethical review committee of the Central Research Laboratory, Federal University of Technology Akure, Nigeria (reference number not applicable) and were in accordance with both the national and international safety regulations and ethical principles for animal welfare. The authors also confirm that they have followed EU standards for the protection of animals used for scientific purposes.
Consent for publication
The authors declare that they have no financial or non-financial competing interests that are directly or indirectly related to this work.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Ayebidun, O.V., Ajibare, A.O. Sub-lethal toxicity of indigo dye (Indigofera tinctoria) on Oreochromis niloticus juveniles. Bull Natl Res Cent 47, 86 (2023). https://doi.org/10.1186/s42269-023-01060-7
- Behavioural responses
- Cell vacuolation
- Indigo dye