- Open Access
Adsorption performance of coated bentonite via graphene oxide
Bulletin of the National Research Centre volume 44, Article number: 53 (2020)
The nano-adsorbents present considerable decontamination potential due to their unique characteristics. This study aimed to investigate the adsorption efficiency and capacity of synthesized nano graphene oxide coated layer over Egyptian clays (bentonite, kaolinite and feldspar) as substrate. The experimental work involves nano graphene oxide coating using acid dehydration via sulfuric acid in presence of different percentage of sugar (fine powder from 1 to 7%), followed by thermal activation to improve the adsorption capacity of natural clay that is locally available in Egypt. Several operating parameters were studied to prepare the superior adsorbent (type of substrate, sulfuric acid concentration, sugar concentration and contact time).
The optimum preparation conditions of nano graphene oxide coated bentonite (NGOCB) adsorbent were bentonite substrate 1 kg, sulfuric acid concentration 1.5 kg/kg clay, sugar fine powder 50 g/kg clay, water 3000 ml/kg clay, and stirring time of 30 min at 100 °C. The morphology characterization showed that the deposited graphene oxide layer is in the nano form (6 to 33 nm). Sets of experiments were conducted to evaluate the adsorption performance of synthesized NGOCB for removal of methylene blue (MB) dye from aqueous solutions. Effect of initial dye concentration, contact time, pH and temperature on the adsorption capacity of the modified adsorbent were studied. The capacity of the prepared nano graphene oxide coated bentonite adsorbent was 1000 mg/g.
The removal efficiency of nano graphene coated clay reached to 99.9% that indicates the Egyptian bentonite could be employed as a low-cost absorbent for dye removal.
Water contamination is a serious problem for human society due to tens of thousands of dyes that exist in sewage waters from different industries such as food, textiles, cosmetics, paper, printing, carpets and leather. It is estimated that the quantity of dyes discharged in wastewater stream in the environment is about 1–2% loss during production and 1–10% loss during uses (Pandey and Ramontja 2016). As small quantities of dyes can badly impact on water bodies, it must be treated before disposal (Ramakrishna and Viraraghavan 1997). Most of the government organizations and water industries try to develop cost-effective technologies for wastewater treatment and reclamation due to increasing demand of fresh water (Toor 2010). Developing effective and low-cost adsorbents has great importance for controlling water contamination (Zhao et al. 2018). Adsorption is a surface phenomenon and interacts via physical forces with pollutants that may be adsorbed on the solid surface. However, weak chemical bonding may be also involved in the adsorption process (Pandey and Ramontja 2016). Moreover, it is known as an effective and economic procedure for wastewater purification. As it is simple in operation, it is a cost-effective and an efficient method for removal of both organic and inorganic pollutants from contaminated waters (Nigam et al. 1996; Annadurai et al. 2002). Currently, activated carbon is the most commercial system that can be used as sorbent to remove dyes in wastewater (Sophia et al. 2019). In spite of its excellent adsorption ability, its application is restricted due to high cost (Derbyshire et al. 2001). Also, activated carbon has other drawbacks such as non-selective and ineffective against disperse and vat dyes, which force scientists to search for more economic adsorbents (Babel and Kurniawan 2003). For improving adsorption capacity of natural clay, various methods were proposed such as acid activation (Emmerich et al. 2009), treatment with cationic surfactant (He et al. 2006), clay-rubber composite (Dai and Huang 1991), thermal treatment (Al-Asheh et al. 2003), polymer addition, plasma (de LB et al. 2008) adsorption and ion exchange with inorganic and organic cations, binding of inorganic and organic anions (mainly at the edges) and grafting of organic compounds (Liu 2007). Graphene oxide-calcium alginate composite has an absorptive capacity 20 times greater than acid-activated bentonite clay (Fatihaa and Belkacem 2016; Li et al. 2013). In this work, a novel technique was presented for conversion of bentonite clay into high adsorption capacity absorbent. The bentonite clay was used as a substrate for deposition of nano graphene oxide layer which has an expected absorptive capacity more than 100 times greater than activated carbon. The present work aims to use fine powder sugar in the presence of sulfuric acid to deposit a thin layer of graphene oxide over the clay surface to prepare nano structure nano graphene oxide coated bentonite with spherical surface morphology. Hence, the adsorption capacity of natural clay was improved. The prepared graphene oxide was investigated as highly efficient and low-cost adsorbent for wastewater treatment especially in dye removal from aqueous solutions or suspensions.
Figure 1 shows the raw kaolinite, bentonite and feldspar bloke used in this study. Chemical composition of the used clays were provided in Table 1. Fine powder of sugar produced by El Hawamdeya Sugar Production Company in Egypt was used as carbon source for graphene oxide layer preparation. Sulfuric acid 98% was used for activation. All used reagents were of analytical grade.
The adsorbent was applied for removal of the basic dye methylene blue (MB), which is a heterocyclic aromatic compound, dark green, and solid at room temperature. The chemical structure of the MB is shown in Table 2.
The wavelength corresponding to the maximum absorbance (ƛmax) was detected at 660 nm using single beam (UV-Vis) spectrophotometer as shown in Fig. 2. This wavelength was selected to measure the absorbance of residual concentration of MB dye, while Fig. 3 shows the relation of MB concentration and the absorbance obtained at the optimum wave length (660 nm). The following equation is used to measure the dye concentration remained:
where Y is absorbance and X is MB dye concentration.
Synthesis of adsorbents
The bentonite clay was mixed with different weights of sugar as described in the following:
Clay grinding and sieving: kaolinite, bentonite and feldspar blokes were grinded then sieved to the desired particle size,
About 100 g of clay was mixed with fine powder sugar (1–7 g),
200 ml of concentrated sulfuric acid was added,
Heating the mixture gently till the hydration reaction started,
After the dehydration reaction completed, 300 ml distilled water was added with stirring then the mixture is boiled for 30 min to activate the deposited graphene oxide layer,
After cooling, the filtration followed by washing was carried out till the pH reached to 7,
Then drying is carried out at 105 °C.
Equilibrium experiments were performed to determine the adsorption capacity of the adsorbent as following: 0.5 g of the coated graphene oxide clay was added to 50 ml of MB solution (100 mg/l) then stirring for 5 min and filtration. After that, the absorbance of the filtrate was measured at 660 nm to determine the concentration of residual MB dye. The concentration and adsorption capacity of dye were calculated using the following equation:
where qe (mg/g) denote the equilibrium adsorption capacity,
Ci is the initial concentration of MB (mg/l),
Cf is the final concentration of the MB (mg/l),
M is the mass of the adsorbent (g),
and V is the volume of the dye solution (L).
Clay coated graphene oxide morphology
The shape and size of the obtained clay coated with graphene oxide was characterized using a JEOL-JEM-1200 transmission electron microscope (TEM). The TEM sample was prepared by adding a drop of the graphene oxide coated clay suspension solution after sonication for 15 min on a 400-mesh copper grid coated by an amorphous carbon film and lifting the sample to dry in air at room temperature. The average diameter of the clay coated particles was determined within 100 nanoparticles found in several chosen areas in enlarged microphotographs. Also, X-ray diffraction test was carried out using X-ray diffraction-type BRUKER apparatus, D8 ADVANCE, Cu target wavelength 1.54 A 40 kV, 40 mA (Germany).
X-ray diffraction (XRD) scans of graphene oxide was performed with Bruker’s D8 advanced X-ray diffractometer using CuKα radiation (λ = 1.5418 ̊A). Dynamic light scattering (model no: HORIBA Nano particle analyzer SZ 100) was used to measure the size of the particle.
Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR)
Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) was performed to identify types of chemical bonds, i.e. functional groups in a molecule (model no: Perkin Elmer precisely FT-IR spectrometer) over the wave number range of 4000–500 cm−1.
Effect of clay substrate type
For nano graphene oxide layer deposition, the clay substrate (100 g), sugar (fine powder, 5 g), sulfuric acid (54 ml) and distilled water (300 ml) were mixed and stirred for 30 min at 100 °C. On studying sulfuric acid as dehydrating solvent, it was found that both kaolinite and feldspar yields were decreased to 40 and 70%, respectively. This may be attributed to dissolution of the substrate in the concentrated sulfuric acid medium due to the presence of free aluminum oxide as illustrated in Table 1 and other minerals such as sodium oxide, potassium oxide and others which are soluble in concentrated sulfuric acid. On the other hand, in the case of bentonite only 5% of the substrate dissolution was observed as shown in Fig. 4. Stability of bentonite clay may be attributed to the presence of aluminum in combined state with silica as montmorillonite which is insoluble hydrated sodium calcium aluminum magnesium silicate hydroxide (Na, Ca)0.33(Al, Mg)2(Si4O10)(OH)2·nH2O. So, bentonite clay was selected as the optimum substrate for nano graphene oxide deposition based on the above discussion.
Effect of sulfuric acid concentration
The effect of sulfuric acid concentration on both the nano graphene oxide coated bentonite clay yield (adsorbent) and the adsorption efficiency for removal MB dye is graphically shown in Fig. 5. On studying the effect of sulfuric acid addition in synthesis of graphene oxide coated bentonite clay, it was clear that as the sulfuric acid concentration increases, the coated clays by graphene oxide yield decreases from 98% at sulfuric acid dose 50g/100g clay to 55% at 250g/100g clay. On the other hand, as the sulfuric acid amount increases from 150gm/100gm to 250gm/100gm clay, the adsorption capacity of NGOCB for MB solution increases from 60 to 98%. So, the amount of sulfuric acid 150g/100g clay was selected as optimum.
Effect of sugar concentration
Addition of sugar on bentonite with different amounts was studied. Figure 6 shows the effect of sugar concentration on both bentonite graphene oxide coated clay yield and MB removal efficiency from its solution. It is clear that as the sugar concentration increased above 50g/kg clay, no change of bentonite graphene oxide coated clay yield was observed. This may be attributed to that certain outer surface area of the bentonite substrate which will be saturated with fixed amount of graphene formed from the dehydration of sugar powder. While the sugar fine powder concentration increases, the removal efficiency of the methylene blue from the solutions increases reaching 98% at optimum sugar dose. From the abovementioned results, it is concluded that the optimum operating conditions for the synthesis of bentonite coated by nano graphene oxide layer using sugar fine powder as source of carbon were bentonite substrate 1 kg, sulfuric acid concentration 1.5 kg/kg clay, sugar fine powder 50 g/kg clay, water 3000 ml/kg clay, and stirring time 30 min at 100 °C. Figure 7 illustrates the shape and color of the obtained adsorbent due to the change of sugar powder addition; it is clear that as the sugar dose increases, the color changes from buff to black which indicates the formation of graphene oxide layer.
Preparation of nano fertilizer from acid waste
After the activation process, the resulted slury is filterted to get the graphene oxide coated bentonite. The filtrate is mainly highly concentrated sulfuric acid solution. This acid solution may be used for prepration of nano fertilizer to reach the so-called zero liquid discharge (ZLD) process as mentioned previously by Hussein et al. 2019.
Adsorption capacity optimization
In order to get the maximum adsorption capacity of the prepared nano graphene oxide coated bentonite for MB removal, several operating conditions have to be investigated such as nano graphene oxide adsorbent dose, stirring time, initial MB solution pH and temperature.
Effect of NGOCB clay amount on the adsorption efficiency
The removal efficiency of MB dye 100 mg/l with different doses of bentonite coated with nano graphene oxide layer prepared via the optimum operating conditions mentioned above were represented in Fig. 8. The adsorption experiments were carried out at a stirring time of 15 min with a stirring rate of 150 rpm then settling for 10 min and filtration of the decanted solution. It is clear from this data that as the dose of the coated clay increases, the adsorption efficiency increases reaching its maximum (98%) at 15min for 20 g/l.
Effect of NGOCB dose on contact time
The removal efficiency was studied at different time intervals as shown in Fig. 9. It illustrates that the uptake attained equilibrium after 15 min for NGOCB and the removal efficiency reached 98%, while in literature the time needed for equilibrium was 3 h (Pandey and Ramontja 2016). These results revealed that the stirring time is inversely proportional to the quantity of adsorbent, i.e. increasing dose of NGOCB decreases the time required for maximum removal. On using 1 g of coated clay per one liter of MB solution (100 ppm), the time required was 60 min to reach to maximum removal of dye, while on adding a dose of 20 g/l, the time required was only 15 min for complete removal. So, from the economical point of view and the engineering design parameters, it is recommended to use the dose 5 g/l for 40 min as a considerable amount and a short time was required.
Effect of initial pH
As shown in Table 3, the adsorption of the dye with pH from 4 to 11 were studied, keeping all other parameters constant. It was observed that the amount of dye absorbed per unit weight of absorbent increased as the increasing pH value. This is due to electrostatic force between the adsorbent and positively charged basic dyes which become less. This is in good agreement with the results reported before (Pandey and Ramontja 2016).
Effect of temperature
By increasing the temperture of MB solution from 25 to 60 °C, it is clear that increasing the temperature increases the pecent removal of MB from 99 to 99.6% at 40 °C then it remains constant at 60 °C which means that the temperature almost has no effect on NGOCB adsorption capacity throughout this study as shown in Table 4.
Graphene oxide coated bentonite surface morphology
The sample of the NGOCB (bentonite coated with nano graphene oxide) prepared at the optimum conditions was studied by TEM test and SAED (a and c) to obtain the surface morphology. It was found that the obtained particles are in spherical shape with a diameter that ranged from 6 to 33 nm as shown in photo (a) and the histogram (b) of the prepared sample which was shown in Fig. 10. The histogram shows that the major particle sizes present of the optmium NGOCB (42%) is 6 nm while the minor particle sizes is 33 nm which represents 5% of the sample. The selected area electronic diffraction pattern (SAED) (c) test illustrates that the obtained coat over the bentonite clay is defintely graphene oxide layer. The presence of internal points with higher light intensities than other external points clearly indicated the presence of graphene oxide mono-layers with hexagonal pattern and structure containing a smaller number of layers, which is in good agreement with the results of previous work (Hack et al. 2018). X-ray diffraction of nano graphene oxide was performed to determine the crystal structure of graphene oxide obtained by this method. As shown in Fig. 11, it gave one sharp peak for graphene oxide at 15.59°. Also, it indicated that graphite was completely oxidized to graphene oxide due to the disappearance of graphite peak at 10.5°. Moreover, the interlayer distance of graphene oxide (d spacing) was calculated (0.077 Å). The compositional analysis of graphene oxide was performed with the aid of FTIR (Fig. 12) over the range of 390–3890 nm. The wide band observed in graphene oxide between 3500 and 3100 is attributed to the O–H (hydroxyl group), stretching vibrations of C–OH and observed water molecules. The peak observed at 1627 is due to the combined effect of C=C and C=O vibrations. The adsorption bands between 850 and 800 nm are credited to the C–H bond vibration. Also, spikes at 650–600 nm arise from C–H bonding vibration.
Adsorption capacity of the graphitized clay
The graphene oxide source in this study is the dehydration reaction of fractose according to Eq. 4:
The complete dehydration of one mole of sugar (180 g) will give 72 g of carbon. With respect to our results, 5 g sugar/100g bentonite clay was selected as optmium. Then, 5 g sugar will give 2 g carbon per 100 g clay, i.e. 20 g graphene oxide/kg bentonite clay.
The results show that 5 g of the NGOCB is cabable for the removal of 100 mg of MB dye from its solution. This means that 100 mg net graphene oxide coat is cabable for removal of 100 mg of MB dye. By calculations, 1 g of net graphene oxide coat could remove 1000 mg of MB dye from its solution which indicates that the adsorption capacity of the NGOCB adsorbent is 1000 mg/g adsorbent which is more than five times than that cited in the previous work (Li et al. 2013). It is expected to increase the adsorption capacity about 10 times by improving the conversion of graphene oxide to graphene layer by reduction process to modify the adsorbent which will require more investigation.
According to the traditional graphene oxide-calcium alginate composite with MB adsorption capacity (183 mg/g) which was prepared by the Hummer method (Li et al. 2013) and comparing this with our prepared graphitized bentonite with adsorption capacity (1000 mg/g net graphene), and with using a filtration process to evaluate both types in removal of MB with fixed volumes of them, it is found that our filter has removal efficency of 36 times more than that of traditional graphene oxide-calcium alginate using the same dose at the same contact time. On the other hand, regarding the cost of NGOCB against the traditional one, it was found that the capital cost of NGOCB was about 30% (350$/kg) of the traditional graphene capital cost (1100$/kg).
Graphene oxide coated bentonite in nano form (NGOCB) was prepared by the dehydration reaction of sugar powder using concentrated sulfuric acid in the presence of Egyptian bentonite clay as carrier substrate followed by thermal activation in aqueous medium. Several operating parameters were studied to get the optimum preparation conditions such as the type of substrate, sulfuric acid concentration and sugar powder concentration, and the prepared adsorbent samples’ adsorption capacity were tested using methylene blue dye as adsorbate. The surface morphology, FTIR, TEM and XRD of the optimum adsorbent sample was carried out to get a complete characterization of the target nano graphene oxide coated bentonite powder. The optimum preparation conditions were bentonite substrate 1 kg, sulfuric acid concentration 1.5 kg/kg clay, sugar fine powder 50 g/kg clay, water 3000 ml/kg clay, and stirring time 30 min at 100 °C. The selection of the substrate clay is based on the resistance of the clay to the sulfuric acid dissolution to maximize the amount of adsorbent yield. It was found that the bentonite structure has the lowest solubility in sulfuric acid flowed by feldspar, then kaolinite. This may be attributed to that the bentonite structure has aluminum in combined state with silica as montmorillonite which is insoluble hydrated sodium calcium aluminum magnesium silicate hydroxide (Na, Ca)0.33(Al, Mg)2(Si4O10)(OH)2·nH2O. This formula is always used for the preparation of bleaching earth (RREF) due to its resistance to acid dissolution, so bentonite was selected as the optimum substrate for deposition of graphene oxide layer. At the optimum conditions, it will be sure that all the sugar amounts is consumed and converted to graphene oxide, and excess amount of sulfuric acid may leach the deposited graphene oxide layer to the activation medium which leads to the decrease of the adsorption capacity; so, 150 g/kg clay of sulfuric acid is considered as optimum. Regarding sugar powder amount, it is believed that the precipitated graphene oxide layer have to be in the form of one to nine layers to be as graphene or graphene oxide, while if more than nine layers it will be deposited as a graphite layer which has an adsorption capacity less than that of graphene or graphene oxide. So, at the optimum selected sugar dose is suitable for the maximum methylene blue dye removal which has matching presence of graphene oxide layer. Due to the concept of ZLD (zero liquid discharge), the wastewater carried during this process is mainly sulfuric acid solution with a minimum amount of nano carbon particles, so by the neutralization of this water by potassium hydroxide liquid nano fertilizer, it will be prepared with high cash flow in the production process as shown by Hussein et al. (2019). Several adsorption conditions were studied to maximize the obtained adsorbent (NGOCB) adsorption capacity of methylene blue dye from its solutions; these conditions were NGOCB dose, pH, contact time, temperature and initial dye concentration. From experimental results, it was found that the optimum adsorption condtions were pH 11, contact time 40 min, 5 g NGOCB/l of 100 mg/l methylene blue, temperature 25 °C. From the TEM analysis, the obtained NGOCB has spherical particles of diameter that ranged from 6 to 33 nm with a major percentage of 42% of 6 nm particles and 3% of minor percentage of 33 nm particles as indicated by histogram. SAED and XRD analyses indicate the presence of monolayer graphene oxide over the surfaces of the bentonite clay with hexagonal structure.
The adsorption of basic dye methylene blue was investigated using Egyptian bentonite clay coated with graphene oxide layer, and it was concluded that:
The optimum conditions for maximum adsorption capacity of MB dye by NGOCB were 150 g sulfuric acid per 100 g bentonite clay and using 5 g fine sugar powder.
Addition of sugar improves the removal of methylene blue to reach 99.95% at 15 min due to the increase in the adsorption capacity of graphene oxide coated bentonite.
The syntheized NGOCB, at the optmium conditions, has a nano size structure ranged from 6 to 33nm.
Adsorption behaviour was insensitive to the temperature change due to low activation energy in the ionic system.
Increasing the dose of NGOCB decreases the time required for maximum removal of dye. The net adsorption capacity of graphene oxide layer coated over bentonite clay is raised to 1000 mg/g which is more than five times the adsorption capacity of graphene oxide-calcium alginate composite.
Availability of data and materials
Nano graphene oxide coated bentonite
Transmission electronic microscope
Selected area electron diffraction
Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy
Al-Asheh S, Banat F, Abu-Aitah L (2003) Adsorption of phenol using different types of activated bentonite. Sep Pur Tech. 33:1–10
Annadurai G, Juang RS, Lee DJ (2002) Use of cellulose-based waste for adsorption of dyes from aqueous solutions. J Hazardous Mater B92:263–274
Babel S, Kurniawan TA (2003) Low-cost adsorbents for heavy metals uptake from contaminated water: a review. J Hazardous Mater. B97:219–243
Boulos TR, Ibrahim SS, Yehia A (2015) Differential flotation of some Egyptian feldspars for separation of both silica and iron oxides contaminants. J Minerals Mater Characterization Eng 3:435–443
Dai JC, Huang JT (1991) Surface modification of clays and clay rubber composite. Appl Clay Sci. 15:51–65
de LB P, Morales AR, FRV D, Organoclays (2008) Properties, preparation and applications. Appl Clay Sci. 42:8–24
Derbyshire F, Jagtoyen M, Andrews R, Rao A, Martin-Gullon I, Grulke E (2001) Carbon materials in environmental applications. In: Radovic LR (ed) Chemistry and Physics of Carbon, vol 27. Marcel Dekker, New York, pp 1–66
Emmerich K, Steudel A, Weidler P (2009) Alteration of swelling clay minerals by acid activation. Appl Clay Sci. 44:105–115
Fatihaa M, Belkacem B (2016) Adsorption of methylene blue from aqueous solutions using natural clay. J Mater Environ Sci. 7(1):285–292
Hack R, Correia C, De Simone Zanon RA, Pezzin SH (2018) Characterization of graphene nano sheets obtained by a modified Hummer’s method, Matéria (Rio J.) vol.23 no.1 Rio de Janeiro.
Hassan MS, Abdel-Khalek NA (1998) Beneficiation and applications of an Egyptian bentonite. Appl Clay Sci 13:99–115
He H, Frost RL, Bostrom T, Yuan P, Duong L, Yang D, Xi Y, Kloprogge T (2006) Changes in morphology of organo clays with HDTMA surfactant loading. Appl Clay Sci. 31:262–271
Hussein HS, Shaarawy HH, Hussien Nabila H, Hawash SI (2019) Preparation of nano-fertilizer blend from banana peels. Bull Natl Res Centre 43:26
Li Y, Du Q, Liu T, Sun J, Wang Y, Wu S, Wang Z, Xia Y, Xia L (2013) Methylene blue adsorption on graphene oxide/calcium alginate composites. Carbohydrate Polymers 95(1):501–507
Liu P (2007) Polymer modified clay minerals: a review. Appl Clay Sci. 38:64–76
Nigam P, Banat IM, Singh D, Marchant R (1996) Microbial process for the decolorization of textile effluent containing azo, diazo and reactive dyes. Process Biochem 31(5):435–442
Pandey S, Ramontja J (2016) Natural bentonite clay and its composites for dye removal: current state and future potential. Am J Chem Appl 3(2):8–19
Ramakrishna KR, Viraraghavan T (1997) Dye removal using low cost adsorbent Wttl. Sri Tick. 36(2-3):189–196
Sophia C, Arfin T, Lima EC (2019) Recent developments in adsorption of dyes using graphene based nanomaterials, in a book: A New Generation Material Graphene: Applications in Water Technology
Toor MK (2010) Enhancing adsorption capacity of bentonite for dye removal: physiochemical modification and characterization Master thesis in Engineering Science.
Yahaya S, Jikan SS, Badarulzaman NA, Adamu AD (2017) Chemical composition and particle size analysis of kaolin, Path of Science: International Electronic Scientific Journal, Vol. 3, No 10.
Zhao W, Zhu J, Wei W, Ma L, Zhu J, Xie J (2018) Comparative study of modified/non-modified aluminum and silica aerogels for anionic dye adsorption performance. RSC Adv. 8:29129
The authors would like to express their appreciation to the National Research Centre Fund for the financial support and many thanks for central lab in NRC and all the teamwork.
This work was done in the National Research Centre, Egypt, which has funded all the experimental work.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
Consent for publication
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Shaarawy, H.H., Hussein, H.S., Kader, E.A. et al. Adsorption performance of coated bentonite via graphene oxide. Bull Natl Res Cent 44, 53 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1186/s42269-020-00299-8
- Graphene oxide
- Methylene blue