Effect of exogenous salicylic acid or indole acetic acid on their endogenous levels, germination, and growth in maize

Background: Exogenous hormone applications modify the plant growth and development by inducing changes in their endogenous contents. However, it is not clear whether the effects of exogenous hormones on growth are direct or related with changes induced in endogenous hormones. Laboratory and greenhouse experiments were conducted to study the effect of exogenous salicylic acid (SA) or indole acetic acid (IAA) on endogenous levels in soaked seeds, 5-day-old seedlings, and in vegetative growth of foliar-sprayed plants. The effects of different concentrations of two hormones on germination and growth of maize were also studied. Results: The effect of presoaking maize seeds in solutions of SA or IAA (0, 0.25, 0.5, 1, and 2 mM) on their endogenous contents in soaked seeds or in 5-day-old seedlings. Soaked seeds absorbed more SA than IAA. In young seedlings, the majority of two hormones which absorbed during seed soaking remained in the residual seeds. Presoaking seeds in SA or IAA solutions suppressed the growth of 5-day-old seedlings. In the greenhouse experiment, endogenous SA and IAA increased after spraying two compounds at 0.25–2 mM, peaking 2 days after treatment then decreased on. However, plants treated with SA at 1 mM or 2mM continued to pose higher levels of endogenous SA, 8 days later. At 20 days after treatments, all tested concentrations of two hormones significantly increased the fresh and dry weights of the whole plant. These inducing effects disappeared 40 days after spraying. Conclusion: The obtained results demonstrated the changes in endogenous SA and IAA in soaked seeds, seedling, and foliar-sprayed plants due to their exogenous application. However, concentrations of two hormones did not produce any permanent enhancement effects on germination and plant growth.


Background
Salicylic acid (SA) and indole acetic acid (IAA) are plant hormones involved in the regulation of many physiological processes in plants. Interestingly, these two hormones share a common precursor-chorismate, the final product of the shikimate pathway. Chorismate is responsible for aromatic amino acids including tryptophan, and through several steps, it can generate the IAA. Meanwhile, chorismate can be converted into isochorismate which transformed into SA (Pérez-Llorca et al. 2019).
SA is a phenolic compound, which contributes to the regulation of many growth and development processes, such as seed germination, photosynthesis, respiration, flowering, and senescence (Vicente and Plasencia 2011). Moreover, SA also acts as a signaling molecule in the activation of the plant defense responses against many stress factors (Wani et al. 2017), whereas IAA is one of the most important phytohormones, and it plays essential roles in different processes, including gametogenesis, embryogenesis, seedling growth, vascular patterning, and flower development (Zhao 2010). Endogenous hormones are tightly controlled through various mechanisms, such as biosynthesis, degradation, transportation, and conjugate formation (Korasick et al. 2013). However, it is not clear whether the effects of exogenous hormones on plant growth are direct or whether they are connected with their effects on endogenous hormones (Szalai et al. 2011). In most tissues, the endogenous IAA responded in a distinct manner to varying amounts of exogenous IAA application . Moravcová et al. (2018) studied the effect of pre-treatment of maize seeds with SA in different concentrations on the level of endogenous SA. They found that soaking seeds in SA at 50 μM resulted in a significant increase in endogenous SA, but application 500 μM produced a significant decrease in the level of endogenous SA in the newly formed roots, whereas soaking pea seeds in SA caused increases in both free and pound SA contents in the seeds (Szalai et al. 2011). Higher levels of endogenous IAA might cause an inhibitory effect, so the optimum endogenous level must be controlled. Cai et al. (2018) found that at 3 days after exogenous application of SA, the endogenous SA reached the maximum and subsequently decreased until it reached the level of control plants at 7 days later.
In the present study, we investigated the effect of presoaking maize seeds in SA or IAA on germination, uptake, and distribution of endogenous hormones in young seedlings. Moreover, growth effects and the changes in the endogenous SA and IAA over time as a response to spraying of two hormones in leaves of greenhousegrown maize were also studied.

Source of plants
Seeds of maize (Zea mays cv. Giza 2) were obtained from Agricultural Research Center, Egypt.

Germination experiment
Maize seeds of the same size were sterilized with 10% (v/v) sodium hypochlorite solution for 5 min and washed with distilled water. Seeds were soaked for 48 h in the dark at 25°C in distilled water (control) or in either SA or IAA solutions four different concentrations for each (0.25, 0.5, 1, and 2 mM). The soaked seeds were germinated in Petri dishes. Ten seeds of each treatment were placed in a 9-cm plastic Petri dish lined with a single Whatman No. 1 filter paper, then 10 mL of distilled water was added onto filter paper. Four replicates of each treatment were placed, in a completely randomized manner, in a growth chamber at 25°C. After 5 days, germination percentage, shoot length, and root length of germinated seeds were determined. Moreover, endogenous SA and IAA were determined in soaked seeds before incubation as well as in various tissues of young seedlings.

Greenhouse experiment
An experiment was conducted to study the effect of foliar spray of SA or IAA on growth and the changes in endogenous SA and IAA over time of greenhouse-grown maize. The seeds were sown on May 1, 2018, in pots (30-cm diameter) filled with 4 kg soil (sand: peat moss, 3:1, w/w) at 5 maize seeds per pot. Ten days after complete germination, three seedlings were preserved in each pot. Then, pots were divided into nine groups with four replicates; each group was sprayed with one of the following treatments: distilled water (control) or SA solution (0.25, 0.5, 1, and 2 mM) or IAA solution (0.25, 0.5, 1, and 2 mM). The solution was sprayed using an Epoca sprayer (Italy) evenly over the entire surface of the plant, including the adaxial and abaxial surface of leaves. The pots were placed in a greenhouse (25 ± 3°C, 12 h photoperiod), arranged in a completely randomized design and irrigated with equal amounts of half-strength Hoagland solution. At 2, 4, and 8 days after treating (DAT), vegetative plant samples were taken to determine the endogenous concentration of SA and IAA. Moreover, at 20 and 40 DAT, plant growth parameters were evaluated in terms of plant height (cm), leaves' number, fresh and dry weights of leaves (g), and fresh and dry weights of a plant (g).

Extraction and determination of SA and IAA
Vegetative plant samples were collected, fast cleaned with distilled water to remove the SA or IAA residues, oven-dried at 50°C, and ground in a mortar. The extraction of endogenous SA and IAA was performed according to Matallo et al. (2009). One hundred milligrams of plant powder was placed in a centrifuge tube, and 10 mL of acidified water (pH 2.5) was added and subjected to an ultra-sonication bath with an ultrasonic frequency of 50/60 Hz for 30 min. Samples were subjected to centrifugation at 4000 g for 10 min at 20°C. The supernatant was collected and filtered through a nylon filter 45 μm. Quantification of SA and IAA was performed by highperformance liquid chromatography (HPLC), LC-10 AD, Shimadzu, Japan. The two phytohormones were analyzed using a Luna RP-C18 (2) column (250 × 4.6 mm i.d, 5 μm, Phenomenx). The mobile phase of phosphate buffer (pH 6.5) in methanol (90:10, v/v) was used at a flow rate 0.9 mL/min. The detecting wavelength was 220 nm. Standard of SA and IAA were purchased from Sigma Aldrich. For each compound, the calibration curve was constructed with the concentrations of the standards (0.01-0.1 mg/mL) that covered the range of levels of the compounds found in the plant tissues. The retention time in min was 9.42 for SA and 10.29 for IAA.

Statistical analysis
Analyses were performed in triplicate. The data were subjected to analysis of variance according Gomez and Gomez (1984), and comparison of means (LSD, 5% level) was performed using Stat graphics Plus Version 5.1.

Germination experiment
As shown in Table 1, soaking maize seeds in SA solutions at 0.25-2 mM for 48 h caused gradual increases the endogenous SA in treated seeds when compared with water-soaked seeds. Concentration and amount of SA in SA-soaked seeds ranged between 19.1 and 152.2 μg/g and between 6.8 and 55.2 μg/seed compared with 0.7 of μg/g and 0.3 μg/seed for control seeds, respectively. It was found that the endogenous SA content was higher than those found in the corresponding control (Table 1). Pre-treating seeds with the highest concentration of SA (2 mM) resulted in a great accumulation of this compound and a complete inhibition in the germination of maize seeds. No great differences in the concentration of endogenous SA between developed roots and developed shoots of SA-pretreated seedlings. These two parts possessed between 8-times to 10-times of endogenous SA, relative to control. Meanwhile, in all tested seedlings, the residual seeds tended to accumulate more amount of SA than those accumulated in shoots or roots.
Soaking maize seeds in IAA solutions for 48 h caused a gradual increase in the concentration and amount of endogenous IAA, as the concentration increased (Table 2). Concentration and amount of endogenous IAA in 2 mM IAA-treated seeds constituted 27.2 μg/g and 9.55 μg/seed corresponded with 1.3 μg/g and 0.5 μg/seed for control, respectively. The application of IAA led to increase the concentration and amount of endogenous IAA in all seedling tissues. The shoot, root, and residual seeds of IAA pre-soaked seedlings possessed between 1.36-1.66, 1.78-3.22, and 2.9-7.73 μg/g, compared with 1.27, 1.56, and 0.97 μg/g for those of control, respectively. The IAA concentration was higher in residual seeds than in the developed roots or shoots of pretreated seedlings. Moreover, the residual seeds tended to accumulate more IAA (0.42-3.42 μg/seed) than those accumulated in the shoots (0.1-0.16 μg/seed) or roots (0.19-0.36 μg/seed) of all tested seedlings.
Pre-soaking seeds in SA or in IAA solutions led to different effects on germination and seedling growth (Table  3). Soaking seeds in higher SA concentration (2 mM) completely inhibited the germination of maize seeds. Also, a significant decrease in the germination percentage was found due to the application of SA at 1 mM or o.5 mM as well as IAA at o.5 mM or 0.25 mM as compared with control (water germinated seeds). On the contrary, the application of low SA dose (0.25 mM) and high IAA dose (2 mM) in the seed pre-treatment caused significant increases in germination percentage when compared with control. Moreover, all SA and IAA pre-treatments caused decreases in shoot length as compared with control. A gradual decrease in shoot length was obtained by increasing the dose of SA pretreatments decreasing the dose of IAA pre-treatments. Hence, the most reduction effect was recorded for the highest SA dose and for the lowest IAA dose. As shown in Table 3, the root length of 5-day-old seedlings exhibited the most reduction effects as affected by presoaking seeds in all SA doses and IAA doses.

Greenhouse experiment
Changes in endogenous SA and IAA over time of greenhouse-grown maize as affected by foliar spray of these two compounds were illustrated in Fig. 1. The results indicated that application SA at 0.25 mM did not produce any remarkable effect on endogenous SA when compared with control, whereas spraying SA at 0.5-2 mM caused a concentration-dependent increase in SA  Fig. 2 demonstrated that the concentration of endogenous IAA was responded positively to all IAA exogenous application treatments when determined at 2 DAT or 4 DAT. Such an increase depended on the concentration, and it ranged between 10% and 34% at 2 DAT and between 3% and 24%, at 4 DAT. However, at 8 DAT, the pronounced increase in the level of endogenous IAA was obtained only by application IAA at 2 mM. The effects of foliar spray of SA on vegetative growth of greenhouse-grown plants are presented in Table 4. At 20 DAT, no significant effects of SA application were observed on plant height and number of leaves as compared with control plants. Also, the lower concentration of SA (0.25 mM) did not cause any changes in most vegetative growth parameters. However, the application of SA at the higher concentrations (0.5-2 mM) produced significant increases in the fresh weight of plants and leaves and dry weight of plants and leaves, as compared with control. Maximum increases in these growth parameters were obtained by treating plants with SA at 2 mM, whereas, at 40 DAT, the enhancing effect of all SA treatments on growth parameters disappeared.
As shown in Table 5, foliar spray of IAA at all tested doses tended to enhance the vegetative growth parameters of maize when measured 20 DAT, but the effect on plant height and number of leaves did not reach the level of significance. Meanwhile, the most effective treatment was obtained by SA at 0.5 mM. This treatment achieved more than 50% increases in fresh and dry weights of leaves and plants, relative to control. At 40 DAT, the significant increase in growth parameters was observed only when application IAA at the highest dose (2 mM). This treatment produced more than 15% increases in different growth traits, as compared with those of control.

Discussion
Exogenous hormone applications modify the plant growth and development by inducing changes in their endogenous contents. However, it is not clear whether the effects of exogenous hormones on growth are direct or whether they are related with changes induced in endogenous hormones (Szalai et al. 2011). We determined the changes in the endogenous SA and IAA after soaking seeds in different concentrations of these two compounds for 48 h and their distribution in seedlings after complete germination of pre-soaked seeds in distilled water for another 5 days. The results indicated that the exogenous applications of SA and IAA were correlated with the changes in their endogenous contents in soaked seeds and 5-day-old seedlings. These results are in line with those obtained by Kim et al. (2006) and Moravcová et al. (2018). Meanwhile, a higher ability of maize seeds for uptake SA was detected when compared with the relatively low ability of seeds on uptake IAA. The low ability of soaked seeds for uptake IAA was previously reported by Kim et al. (2006). Seeds soaked in the highest concentration of SA (2 mM) accumulated a great amount of SA which could be responsible for preventing the germination of seeds. In this respect, a dramatic  inhibition of the germination process was reported when soaking maize seeds in SA above a concentration of 1 mM (Guan and Scandalios 1995), whereas Marambe and Ando (1992) found that increasing the phenolic acid concentrations in germination media reduced water uptake, a-amylase activity, and germination rate of sorghum seeds.
In the present study, we determined the effect of presoaking seeds in SA and IAA on the distribution of endogenous SA and IAA in different tissues of 5-day-old seedlings. The two hormones were found in different seedling tissues, and their contents were positively correlated with the applied concentrations. The major amounts of SA or IAA in the residual seeds of young seedlings, but developed shoots and roots accumulated low amounts of two compounds. In line with these results, Szalai et al. (2011) found that the majority of the SA absorbed during seed soaking remained in the seeds.
In this study, pre-soaking seeds in SA or in IAA solutions for 48 h achieved different effects on germination and seedling growth of 5-day-old maize plants. In the literature, there are divergent data about the effect of different concentrations of SA and IAA on seed germination and seedling development (Rajjou et al. 2006;Chauhan et al. 2009;Xiao et al. 2014). In this study, except for the enhancing effect of lower SA concentration (0.25 mM) and higher IAA one (2 mM) on germination percentage, all SA and IAA treatments negatively reduced the germination percentage of maize seeds. An inhibitory effect of SA on germination percentages of many plant species, especially at high applied concentrations was previously recorded by many investigators (Negi and Prasad 2001;Chandra et al. 2007;El-Mergawi 2019). The inhibitory effect of application high SA concentrations on germination can be attributed to toxic stress (Canakci and Munzuroglu 2007). In this concern, Muscolo et al. (2001) found that the phenolic acids inhibited the germination of pinus laricio by inhibiting the activities of glycolysis and the oxidative pentose phosphate pathway enzymes. However, an enhancing effect of 0.25 mM SA concentration on the germination percentage of the broad bean was reported by Anaya et al. (2018). Regarding the inhibition effect of IAA, Ramaih et al. (2003), Shuai et al. (2017), and Emem et al. (2017) showed that the exogenous application of the IAA delayed seeds germination of wheat, soybean, and Cucumis melo, respectively. Recently, Shuai et al. (2017) suggested that IAA can inhibit the germination process of soybean seeds through enhancing the abscisic-biosynthesis pathway and negatively mediated gibberellic-biosynthesis.
In this study, all SA and IAA treatments suppressed seedling growth of maize, when compared with the control seedlings. Moreover, a gradual decrease in seedling growth of 5-day-old seedlings was obtained by increasing the dose of SA or decreasing the dose of IAA. The most reducing effect was detected by using a higher concentration of SA (2 mM) and lower concentration of IAA (0.25 mM). These results are in general agreement with those obtained by Chandra et al. (2007); they found that both germination and seedling growth of four cowpea genotypes were negatively affected by 0.02% (1.45 mM) SA application. On the contrary, many investigators recorded an enhancement effect on seedling growth due to pretreatment seeds with IAA (Zhao and Zhong 2013) or with SA (Anaya et al. 2018). These contradictory results might be attributed to the variability in species or in applied concentration or in soaking time. Moreover, we found that the inhibitory effect of tested hormones on the root growth of seedlings was apparently greater Table 4 Effect of SA foliar spray on vegetative growth of maize plants Criteria Treatment than that on germination percentage or shoot growth. This result is indirectly in accordance with those reported by El-Mergawi andAl-Humaid (2017, 2019) and El-Mergawi and El-Desoki (2018). These studies showed that root growth was the most sensitive to allelopathic compounds than shoot growth and germination percentage.
The change in endogenous SA and IAA concentrations throughout eight DAT is in response to the exogenous application of two hormones in leaves of greenhouse-grown maize. The results indicated that the endogenous active forms of SA and IAA were responded positively to all their exogenous application treatments peaking at 2 DAT and subsequently decreasing gradually. Different plant species responded in a distinct manner to varying amounts of exogenous SA Guzmán-Téllez et al. 2014 or IAA (Korasick et al. 2013;Al-Amri 2018;Cai et al. 2018) treatments. However, plants treated with SA at 1 and 2 mM only continued to possess higher levels of endogenous SA than those of control over the entire time of the measuring period, whereas, at 8 DAT, the IAA content in the all IAAtreated leaves was not possessed any significant difference as compared with the corresponded control. The rapid decrease in the endogenous SA and IAA, after the peak concentration, seems to be partially due to the transformation of two hormones into its conjugated forms (He et al. 2007;Ludwig-Muller 2011).
The results indicated that spraying SA or IAA at 0.25-2 mM produced significant increases in growth traits of maize plants when measured 20 DAT. The enhancing effect of SA and IAA on plant growth was reported by many investigators Guzmán-Téllez et al. 2014;Khandaker et al. 2018). Although, at 40 DAT, except the increment effect of 2 mM IAA on maize growth, all SA and IAA treatments did not produce any significant effect on tested growth parameters when compared with those of control. In this concern, Guzmán-Téllez et al. (2014) found some differences in the values of stem and leaves of tomato between SA treated plants (0.1 mM) and control plants at 4, 12, and 15 DAT and disappeared at the end of the assay (22 DAT). The disappearance of the enhancing effect of SA and IAA treatments in growth parameters over time may be related with the decrease in the levels of endogenous SA or IAA in treated plants by time as previously mentioned. It is assumed that the endogenous SA or IAA concentrations must be kept at an appropriate level to maintain an enhancement effect on growth parameters (Guzmán-Téllez et al. 2014).

Conclusions
In this study, the effect of pre-soaking maize seeds in SA and IAA on germination, uptake, and distribution of endogenous two hormones in soaked seeds and 5-day-old seedlings was determined. A higher ability of maize seeds on uptake SA was detected accompanied with a relatively lower ability of seeds on uptake IAA. The two hormones were found in different seedling tissues, and its contents were positively correlated with the exogenously applied concentrations. In young seedlings, the majority of two hormones which absorbed during seed soaking localized in the residual seeds. Pre-soaking seeds in SA and IAA solutions suppressed seedling growth of maize. In the greenhouse experiment, endogenous SA and IAA were increased after foliar spray of two compounds at 0.25-2 mM, peaking 2 days after treatment and then decreased on. However, plants treated with SA at 1 mM or 2 mM continued to possess higher levels of endogenous SA, 8 days later. All SA and IAA treatments significantly increased the fresh and dry weights of leaves and plants, when measured after 20 days, whereas by extending the period of measuring to 40 days, most of these inducing effects disappeared. Generally, the obtained results increased our knowledge about the changes induced in endogenous SA and IAA in soaked seeds, seedling tissues, and foliar-sprayed plants due to their exogenous application and their relations with germination and growth in maize.