Skip to main content

Table 2 Characteristics of the included studies, according to Author and year of publication; Place and type of injury, Technique and Parameters in the use of Laser and outcome

From: Photobiomodulation (PBMT) and antimicrobial photodynamic therapy (aPDT) in oral manifestations of patients infected by Sars-CoV-2: systematic review and meta-analysis

Author and Year

Local and type of lesion

Technique applied and Laser parameter

Outcome

BrandĆ£o et. al. (2021)

Upper lip, lower lip and anterior dorsum of tongue. Necrotic and aphthous ulcers

PBMT. 40 mW, beam area 0.04 cm2, 1Ā W/cm 2 irradiance, energy 0.4Ā J and 10Ā J/cm2 creep and 660Ā nm

Symptom relief within 2Ā days and complete resolution of lesions within 11Ā days

BrandĆ£o et. al. (2021)

Upper lip, lower lip and anterior dorsum of tongue. Necrotic areas and aphthous ulcers

PBMT. 40 mW, beam area 0.04 cm2, 1Ā W/cm2 irradiance, energy 0.4Ā J and 10Ā J/cm2 creep and 660Ā nm

Improvement of intraoral lesions in 10Ā days and lip ulcerations there was no improvement until the publication of the case, as well as the clinical case of the patient

BrandĆ£o et. al. (2021)

Lateral edge of tongue and palate. Petechiae and necrotic areas

PBMT. 40 mW, beam area 0.04 cm2, 1Ā W/cm 2 irradiance, energy 0.4Ā J and 10Ā J/cm2 creep and 660Ā nm

Total pain control in 5Ā days

BrandĆ£o et. al. (2021)

Upper and lower lip mucosa. Necrotic and hemorrhagic ulcers

PBMT. 40 mW, beam area 0.04 cm2, 1Ā W/cm 2 irradiance, energy 0.4Ā J and 10Ā J/cm2 creep and 660Ā nm

Pain regression and clinical improvement in 7Ā days

Teixeira et. al. (2021)

Upper and lower lip injury. Hemorrhagic and necrotic ulcers

PBMT and aPDT. 100 mW, 33Ā J/cm2, 0.5Ā J and 5Ā s per point. A total of 6 points were distributed for the injuries. Soon after, an aPDT technique was performed, with 0.01% methylene blue applied to all lesions, and after 3Ā min (pre-irradiation time), the same laser parameters were used, but providing 40Ā s (4Ā J) per lesion, 660Ā nm

Total improvement of the lesion in 3Ā days and healing within the first 24Ā h

Teixeira et. al. (2021)

Upper and lower lip injury. Erythematous lesions

PBMT and aPDT. 100 mW, 33Ā J/cm2, 0.5Ā J and 5Ā s per point. A total of 6 points were distributed for the injuries. Soon after, an aPDT technique was performed, with 0.01% methylene blue applied to all lesions, and after 3Ā min (pre-irradiation time), the same laser parameters were used, but providing 40Ā s (4Ā J) per lesion, 660Ā nm

Total improvement of the lesion after 24Ā h

Teixeira et. al. (2021)

Upper and lower lip injury. Painful scaly lip lesions

PBMT and aPDT. 100 mW, 33Ā J/cm2, 0.5Ā J and 5Ā s per point. A total of 6 points were distributed for the injuries. Soon after, an aPDT technique was performed, with 0.01% methylene blue applied to all lesions, and after 3Ā min (pre-irradiation time), the same laser parameters were used, but providing 40Ā s (4Ā J) per lesion, 660Ā nm

Total improvement of lesions in 3Ā days

Teixeira et. al. (2021)

Upper and lower lip injury. Painful scaly lip lesions

PBMT and aPDT. 100 mW, 33Ā J/cm2, 0.5Ā J and 5Ā s per point. A total of 6 points were distributed for the injuries. Soon after, an aPDT technique was performed, with 0.01% methylene blue applied to all lesions, and after 3Ā min (pre-irradiation time), the same laser parameters were used, but providing 40Ā s (4Ā J) per lesion, 660Ā nm

Complete resolution of lesions within 4Ā days

Ramires et. al. (2021)

Upper and lower lip injury. Extensive necrotic ulcers

PBMT and aPDT. aPDT was performed for 2Ā days. For this, 0.01% methylene blue was applied to all lesions after 5Ā min (pre-irradiation time), 100 mW, 32.14Ā J/cm2, 9Ā J and 9Ā s per point and PBMT 100 mW, 17.8Ā J/cm2, 1Ā J and 10Ā s of irradiation per spot at 660 and 808Ā nm, using a laser device programming tool that changes the wavelength periodically (every 5Ā s)

Wound healing in 4Ā days

Baeder et. al. (2021)

Region between attached gingiva and palate. Ulcers, erythema and vesicles

PBMT. 3Ā J every 2Ā days for 1Ā week, 660Ā nm

Burning ceased in 7Ā days and after 14Ā days, the lesions disappeared completely

Garcez et. al. (2021)

Upper and lower lips and inner labial mucosa of the gingiva. Edema with mucosal desquamation, ulceration and blood crusts on the inner surface of the labial mucosa, gingival petechiae and erythematous/pseudomembranous lesions on the dorsum of the tongue, suggestive of candidiasis

PBMT and aPDT. aPDT was performed using a low power laser and methylene blue as a photosensitizer. 300Ā Ī¼M aqueous methylene blue solution was applied to the lips, palate and tongue with a cotton swab for 1Ā min, followed by irradiation of a laser light source operating at 100 mW and 660Ā nm with the following protocol: 90Ā s, resulting in an energy of 9Ā J per irradiation point and an energy density of 300Ā J/cm2, total of 6 pointsā€”including lips (4 points), palate (2 points) and tongue (4 points), the total irradiation time was 15Ā min. After the aPDT sessions, oral lesions were irradiated with 2Ā J of energy per point to cover the oral mucosa surface bilaterally (5 points on each side) using the same equipment, resulting in 20Ā s of irradiation per point and energy density per stitch of 66Ā J/cm2

Oral lesions improved after 3Ā days of aPDT after which treatment was followed with PBM for 4Ā days. The patient did not complain of discomfort in the tongue and lips after starting the photodynamic treatment with an antimicrobial